May 12, 2019
Joe McPhee/John Butcher
At The Hill of James Magee
Trost TR174 CD
Jason Kao Hwang Burning Bridge
True Sound Recordings TS1
Sonic Miniatures about Edvard Munch’s “The Scream”
Creative Sources CS 531 CD
Larry Ochs-Gerald Cleaver
Songs of the Wild Cave
RogueArt ROG 0084
Something in the Air: Inventive Improvisational Inspirations Are Infinite
By Ken Waxman
As difficult as the idea of creating sophisticated improvisational music may sometimes seem, even more fraught with challenges is finding the inspiration behind any improvisation. Creation may be singular or involve ensembles of varying size, while the influence or incentive for the work may result from examining a work of art, an historical action, a physical or spatial location or even a realized sonic concept. Each of these notable discs defines inspirations in a unique fashion.
Take American violinist Jason Kao Hwang’s Blood (True Sound Recordings TS1) His eight-member Burning Bridge ensemble mixes eastern (pipa and erhu) and western (three brass, double bass and drums) instruments on five of Hwang’s polychromatic compositions which make their points twisting varied musical strands, but without trading efficiency for exoticism. Although reflecting on trauma inflicted on his mother in China and his associates in the Vietnam War, Blood isn’t agit-prop. Instead melancholy and aggression are portrayed through sounds, with, for instance, on the title track, stop-time counterpoint from Steve Swell’s trombone projecting from a bellicose march driven by Andrew Drury’s drums cede space to delicate textures from Wang Guowei’s erhu and Sun Li’s pipa. Although the concluding “Declaration” references and resolves the CD with a peaceful overlay consisting of chromatic pipa strums plus pedal-point modulations from Swell and tubaist Joseph Daley, theatrical woe is balanced by sophisticated virtuosity. Giving the Asian instruments parts that unselfconsciously swing, some of Hwang’s other tunes skip and soar with lively inferences. The two-part “Surge” for example finds string parts swirling around Taylor Ho Bynum’s graceful, kinetic cornet, and if Hwang’s violin solo impresses with calculated flying spiccato then so do Li’s crunching strums whose Blues sensibility is closer to the Mississippi river than the Yangtze.”Surge Part 2” is more memorable, since not only does Daley confirm his breath control as he matter-of-factly slides from basso-like to sopranino-like tones, but the composition’s uniqueness is confirmed when Hwang’s bluesy sweeps and Swell’s plunger yelps erupt from within a sequence that emphasizes string stretches from the traditional Chinese instruments.
Concerned with the realization of musical concepts rather than reflecting tangible actions or emotions is Façons (Microcid 014), a two CD set where the 20-odd-members of Rimouski, Quebec-based GGRIL interpret free music tropes created specifically for the ensemble. Describing exactly his aim, “Organon” by Montreal’s Isaiah Ceccarelli aims to transform the orchestra into a gigantic pipe organ and the inflated crescendo which introduces the piece does just that with a collection of tremolo polyrhythms and polytones making distinctive sonic colors judder every which way. As the organ-like chording intensifies however, helped by wave form pressure from GGRIL’s low-energy synthesizers, individual contributions such as Aleandre Robichaud’s trumpet slurps, undulating split tones from all four reedists plus bell clangs and glockenspiel smacks from percussionist Antoine Létourneau-Berger bring singular personalities forward. By the climatic finale, while brass and reed parts retain the concentrated theme, fissure in the form of idiosyncratic runs from the three electric guitarists, percussion and two violinists creates a contrapuntal challenge. Pm disc 2, rather than concentrated textures, London-based soprano saxophonist John Butcher, who joins the group as it plays his six-part “Local Fixations”, emphasized tonal contrasts. As metallic guitar frails from Olivier D’Amours and Robert Bastien sharpen the exposition, string section modulations join with Robin Servant’s accordion vibrations to create divergent drones. By mid-point, the development divides between solo snatches of high-pitched flute echoes, reed bites and fiddle sweeps plus stop-time from the entire ensemble. An interval of triple-tongued saxophone, bowed bass and guitar plucks creates wider intervals on the penultimate “Collective Memories II” until cogwheel ratchets signal a hushed interval. A concluding sequence, “Floating Amphora” emphasize sul ponticello string bowing, mechanized thumps, cawing brass and reed cries as well as tough rebounds from Éric Normand’s electric bass, until a final orchestral tutti sways into conclusive snorts from Gabriel Rochette-Bériau’s trombone and Mathieu Gosselin’s baritone saxophone that blur the disparate timbres into a distinctive finale.
Shrinking the personnel infinitesimally to one and the inspiration to description, is Lisbon-based cellist Ulrich Mitzlaff’s Sonic Miniatures about Edvard Munch’s “The Scream” (Creative Sources CS 531 CD), During 10 brief tracks Mitzlaff’s cello figuratively examines the famous Norwegian painting from every perspective, using extended techniques to make each diminutive track distinctive. The most significant is “Miniature #5”, a multi-hued sketch in itself. Beginning with the sound of the bow clattering on the ground, it evolves to resonating pizzicato plucks advanced one at a time in ascending pitches, until aggregate stops vibrate all strings with below-the-bridge drags, and then suddenly fade to one concluding twang. Shaded differently, “Miniature #9” is almost as dramatic, with speedy spiccato shuffles shading the melody as it moves at a frenetic pace only to end with lulling timbres. Also displaying col legno pops, chamber music-like formalism, sul ponticello echoes, distinctive low pitches and strongly focused stops, the cellist doesn’t echo the message of Munch’s painting as much as create a distinctive art work of his own.
Original methods of using spatial considerations inspire two other session. Songs of the Wild Cave (RogueArt ROG 0084) was recorded in the dark and silence of a Palaeolithic cave in south western France by Americans, saxophonist Larry Ochs and drummer Gerald Cleaver. The other CD was recorded in the Chihuahuan desert in West Texas by American alto saxophonist Joe McPhee and tenor saxophonist John Butcher, far removed from GGRIL. Named for the massive brick sculptures constructed in the desert by a reclusive American sculptor, the improvisations on At the Hill of James Magee (Trost TR174 CD) were created as much in the desert air as inside the shale-rock structures.
On Songs of the Wild Cave though, shadowy haze masking prehistoric cave paintings and stone walls dripping moisture become part of the program as Ochs and Cleaver first tentatively and then sonorously piece the oppressive quiet with contemporary noises. Fully acclimatized, midway through the program, with a track literally entitled “Deeper”, Ochs’ combination of glossolalia, horn shakes, reed bites and dyspeptic tones breech the opaque air to such an extent that reed cries could bring out ghosts of more than Albert Ayler. Meanwhile the drummer complements these saxophone spurts with cymbal smacks, wood pops and rebounding patterns. Adapting to the cave’s spatial qualities, by “Ringing it In”, the saxophonist’s harsh narrow vibrations and squealing split tones seem to be figuratively digging through the murk and the clay encrusted walls beyond. Dispersing the cavern’s chill, the drummer performs a similar feat, warming the air with subtle tambourine and maracas-like shakes and bass-drum smacks. As the improvisations thicken on the penultimate “Rooted in Clay”, a quasi-melody, never previously heard in these primeval surroundings is constructed out of repeated breaths, slurs and vocalized cries, and molded linearly with bell ringing and rattling strokes. When wide honks and inflated multiphonics bounce off the earth and rocks during the final extended “Light from the Shadows”, it appears as if the title’s promise is fulfilled, Cleaver’s subsequent near-bebop rhythm decorated with intermittent saxophone peeps confirms the sound illumination.
Inventively displaying mediations on a comparable structural challenge on At the Hill of James Magee at least McPhee and Butcher had the advantage of defining their art above ground. At the same time the opportunity to produce sounds within and outside 40-foot high edifices made of shale with iron doors and encompassing shattered glass, rust, flowers and textile shards is as daring as it is unique. Turning acoustics to advantage, natural amplification makes saxophone strategy stand out even more. On “Mine Shaft” for instance, the width of a pit is marked with circular breathing that while touching the saxophone’s highest reaches also relaxes into a melodic theme. Oddly the echoes on Butcher’s “Paradise Overcast” more than the previous improvisation reflect a near-bottomless pit, as his darkened slurs and key percussion are coordinated into a rhythmic smear. Otherwise using vamps and asides to emphasize tonal differences between their horns, the duo’s most profound application of this spatial inspiration is the almost 21-minute introductory “Sometimes Yes, Sometimes No”. Apparently convening from opposite angles of the structures, ghostly reed tones connect in concentric circles of growls and buzzes that inflate as they deepen. The alto saxophonist’s moderated tone compared to the tenor saxophonist’s harsh overblowing fragment in a climatic intermezzo after which watery but lyrical timbres predominate. Individual textural variations appear before a protracted pause with a finale that balances McPhee’s narrowed tweets with dampened snarls from Butcher.
Whether it’s from a cerebral hypothesis or a physical object, fascinating improvisations can have many sources. These CDs show some of the ways this happens.
-for The Whole Note May 2019